Photo of the day: Sight radius comparison, HK VP9 vs 1911


The 5 inch barrel on the 1911 is often lauded for delivering a long sight radius to the gun, which according to its proponents helps make the gun more shootable. How come then its sight radius is basically the same as a 4 inch HK VP9 and a 4.5 inch Glock 17?


  1. I’m sure if one were motivated, they could find a replacement sight for the 1911 that would push the front sight closer to the muzzle and therefore extending the sight line another 1/4″. Although here’s another question: why is the slide for a 4″ barrel almost the same length as that of a 5″ barrel 1911?

  2. Usually has something to do with being striker-fired doesn’t it ?

    That said, if the new HK is well accepted, would be nice if they offer it in a barrel length & “size” to make the most out of the USPSA & IDPA Boxes…

  3. Personally, I’ll take the 1911; like the looks, like the weight; glad to have the “right to choice” here in the USA : )

  4. Basically, for a striker fired gun, you get the barrel length of a Commander in the gun size of a Government Model. 😉

  5. And all this time, I thought the trigger was the secret to the 1911’s shootability…

  6. You know the only thing that keeps me from buying HKs? The mag release. Thats it.

Comments are closed.

Please wait...

Subscribe to the Gun Nuts Newsletter

Get notifications in your email when articles are published, as well as our weekly newsletter packed with exclusive content!
%d bloggers like this: