The judge in the Shirley Katz case has ruled, and Shirley has lost. I’m disappointed, but not surprised.
“The District policy applies to only employees and others working for the District. The policy is known to those persons in advance. They accept their jobs subject to, and knowing, the policy.
Having read the full decision, and as much as it galls me to say this, I think the judge made the right ruling based on the laws in Oregon. Whether or not I think it is morally correct is irrelevant in the purely legal sense.