.410 bore or 20 gauge

As I mentioned earlier, I’m looking to pick up one of the H&R Tamer shotguns, partly to feed my desire for more firearms marketed for “survival”, partly because I like single shot shotguns, and also because I plan to wage war on squirrels on my father in law’s farm come August.

However, I’m now presented with a problem. You see, when I originally formulated this plan, I was unaware that there was a 20 gauge version of the Tamer, I was under the impression that it was going to be .410 or nothing.

Now, I’ve got no beef with the .410, in fact I think it gets a poor rap a lot of the time. That being said, the 20 gauge would take my survival shotgun out of the “dusting squirrels” category, and place it seriously in the area of a true survival weapon, able to perform multiple functions well.

On the other hand, one of the reasons I want this gun is because single shot shotguns are about as user friendly as you can get, and I wanted Mrs. Ahab to be able to shoot and enjoy this gun. A 20 gauge doesn’t particularly bother me, but I don’t really have a solid frame of reference for whether or not she’d be sensitive to the recoil from a 20 or not. So that would be a point for the .410.

Obviously, the whole reason I’m posting this is to get your feedback – it’s a blog after all. So here’s a short pros & cons list for the 20 vs .410.

20 Gauge Pros
– True multi-purpose firearm, for a “survival” shotgun the ability of the 20 gauge to effectively deal with small game, deer sized game, and two legged predators is desirable.

– Wider selection of ammunition, owning to the fact that the 20 gauge is a lot more common that .410 shotguns.

– Less likely to be mocked for having a wimpy little .410.

20 Gauge Cons
– More recoil than a .410, which might be a problem for Mrs. Ahab.

– Ammo is heavier than a .410, which means that I have to carry more weight p/shot.

– Not a 12 gauge.

.410 Bore Pros
– Slightly lighter than the same gun in 20 gauge, easier to handle.

– Ammo is lighter as well, less carry weight is always a good thing.

– Less recoil than the 20.

– Less destructive on small game than 20 gauge.

.410 Bore Cons
– Less ammo selection, especially in the area of slugs and buckshot.

– Less power for things larger than small game, such as deer sized game.

– Likely to be mocked for having a girl’s gun.

Opinions in the comments are welcome and solicited. If it makes any difference, I’m leaning 20 gauge right now.

Please wait...

Subscribe to the Gun Nuts Newsletter

Get notifications in your email when articles are published, as well as our weekly newsletter packed with exclusive content!
%d bloggers like this: